Google, Microsoft, Apple sued over preview icons

 

Summary

Michigan-based networking company sues the tech giants for allegedly infringing on a patent related to document thumbnails used in operating systems.

Events

IT Priorities 2010

Sydney, Australia - 27 Jul 2010
Melbourne, Australia - 28 Jul 2010
Mumbai, India - 4 Aug 2010
Delhi, India - 6 Aug 2010

IDC's Asia/Pacific Cloud Computing Conference 2010
31 Aug 2010

Marriott Hotel, Singapore

A Michigan-based networking company on Wednesday filed a lawsuit against Google, Microsoft, and Apple, alleging that all three tech giants violated a patent it owns on the use of document-preview icons--or thumbnails--in operating systems.

In the suit (PDF), Cygnus Systems targets Google's Chrome, Microsoft's Vista and Internet Explorer 8, and Apple's iPhone, Safari, and Mac OS X as patent infringers. Apple uses the patent-protected technology in its Finder and Cover Flow Mac OS X features, the lawsuit claims.

Cygnus describes the technology covered by the patent as "methods and systems for accessing one or more computer files via a graphical icon, wherein the graphical icon includes an image of a selected portion or portions of one or more computer files."

E-mail messages seeking comment from Google, Microsoft, Apple, and Cygnus' attorney were not immediately returned.

The case was filed in U.S. District Court in Arizona, where company owner Gregory Swartz lives, according to PCWorld.

Cygnus was granted the patent in March 2008, according to the lawsuit, although it first applied for it back in 2001 as a continuation to a 1998 application, according to Ars Technica, which appeared to report the case first.

Cygnus is seeking damages and a permanent injunction to prevent further alleged infringement. It has also indicated that it might go after other companies as defendants.

This article was first published as a blog post on CNET News.com.

Talkback

Add your opinion

In order to post a comment, you need to be registered. (Sign In or register below)

Post your comment
Access data anywhere in the private cloud & enable entirely new efficiencies with EMC VPLEX.
Tech Vendor: EMC

ZDNet Asia Live

US court rejects class action status for Intel antitrust suit http://bit.ly/9AbnMF

Non-green IT products 'marketing suicide': This 50-hectare eco-business park is described as a "living laboratory"... http://bit.ly/aCqko4

great! US court rejects class action status for Intel antitrust suit http://bit.ly/9acwER Good day!

Shocked! RT: @danielgoh: Oh really? RT @scoopsg: (zdnetasia) S'pore marketeers not chirping to Twitter's tune http://scoo.ps/dpkySs

Non-green IT products 'marketing suicide': By Munir Kotadia, ZDNet Australia on July 30, 2010 (8 minutes ago) Vend... http://bit.ly/aCqko4

Asian firms aware of IT snoops. http://bit.ly/9eGRxG

sg marketeers not chirping to twitter's tune http://bit.ly/aRAa1Y - baby steps baby steps

Non-green IT products 'marketing suicide': This 50-hectare eco-business park is described as a "living laboratory"... http://bit.ly/cEkDUD

Non-green IT products 'marketing suicide': At the same time, it seems vendors see green technology as a very high ... http://bit.ly/aCqko4

1 hour 8 minutes ago by greentreats on topsy

Oh really? RT @scoopsg: (zdnetasia) S'pore marketeers not chirping to Twitter's tune http://scoo.ps/dpkySs

@mrcolinlim but of course for more tech updates you can always visit zdnetasia.com

RT @zdnetasia: Searchable Facebook user data posted to Pirate Bay http://bit.ly/ciJQxY

2 hours 5 minutes ago by phyllis777loves on topsy

RT @HazelHassan: Facebook led police to Philippine serial killer -- http://ow.ly/2iGnh

RT @zdnetasia: 10 questions to ask when http://www.zdnetasia.c...

RT @zdnetasia: S'pore marketeers not chirping to Twitter's tune http://bit.ly/bF2aoa

Facebook led police to Philippine serial killer -- http://ow.ly/2iGnh

2 hours 21 minutes ago by hazelhassan on topsy

S'pore marketeers not chirping to Twitter's tune: Marketing via Twitter has not picked up in Singapore, where it s... http://bit.ly/9GEDJS

great! S'pore marketeers not chirping to Twitter's tune http://bit.ly/dotZES Good day!

http://bit.ly/8v7Ov3 S'pore marketeers not chirping to Twitter's tune - ZDNet Asia http://is.gd/dSngs

4 hours 14 minutes ago by easytweeting on topsy

in the mean time, if you need to find PDF eBooks, you may use http://www.findpdf.us/

4 hours 44 minutes ago by findpdf on Researchers find workaround for Adobe PDF fix

Just want to say what a great blog you got here! My appreciation of your work, cause i am an IT student also. Try this one too, http://w...

4 hours 52 minutes ago by winsource on Making the case for Filipino IT entrepreneurship

Hi, We have ton of HP empty cartridges. Could you collect them in our office??
Thanks

1 day 45 minutes ago by Pacific Time Pte Ltd on Recycle your HP print cartridges and get rewards

Thanks Kenneth, for your insights. Good to know people out there can see the issue for what it is, and to do so impassively, that is. ...

2 days 50 minutes ago by yedwin on iPhone 4 shows prudence in procrastination

While I agree that the issues with the device have raised many an eyebrow, I think it's unwise to forget that many phone reviews have...

2 days 2 minutes ago by kennethkoh on iPhone 4 shows prudence in procrastination

The online apple store http://store.apple.com/ is not available now. Maybe it's updating the pricing ;)

2 days 255647 seconds ago by mingnow on iPhone 4 to ring in Singapore on Friday

After an awful silence, finally the prices are out..

2 days 56 minutes ago by melvinchia on iPhone 4 to ring in Singapore on Friday

Glad you discovered the Xfce 4.6 magic. Its other endearing feature is its phenomenal configurability. You can make the desktop look and ...

3 days 2 minutes ago by gnome_refugee on Smitten with Xfce 4

yep, tried them all and xfce with compiz/emerald instead of fvwm is by far the best experience I've had. If you didn't know ther...

3 days 273652 seconds ago by ggolemg on Smitten with Xfce 4

@mingnow: why do you think so? How do you think the FOSS community could tackle this issue? I'm involved in a lot of efforts to get t...

3 days 6 minutes ago by fredericmuller on Taobao initiates Chinese open source revolution

Geez. I would think giving free books and getting kids to school would be a better place to start.

3 days 14 minutes ago by mingnow on India's US$35 tablet--how low can it go?

I think it's great the that country with the biggest internet population is finally contributing back to the open-source world. I thi...

4 days 1 minute ago by mingnow on Taobao initiates Chinese open source revolution

hey.there Im Wendy from a PR Agency.I find your blog interesting and well written.In days to come,we would hold an event. Therefore We ...

4 days 31 minutes ago by wendy on iPhone 4 shows prudence in procrastination

It could be done without all these. Just use the opacity addon of Compiz.

4 days 55 minutes ago by hariks0 on How to get RGBA support in Ubuntu