Buying security products is often a waste of money

By Liam Tung, ZDNet Australia
Tuesday, February 19, 2008 09:15 AM

Businesses waste millions of dollars trying protecting their IT infrastructure but too many investment decisions are corrupted by poorly applied mathematics.

"I believe that industry, by and large, is wasting money on security today," said Gene Hodges, CEO of security firm, Websense.

Hodges said the need to feel secure has lead to business making poor investment decisions when it comes to IT security. This has resulted in money being disproportionately allocated to preventing attacks on IT infrastructure.

"Attacks were, for the '90s and the first half of this decade, focused on the infrastructure and the bad guys' objective was to take down your e-mail system, to take down your network connectivity through DDoS attacks...that's why we bought firewalls and antivirus, IDS and IPS.

"I think spending money on classic infrastructure security gives you a sense of security, but actually, you know ...it doesn't matter that much," he said.

Hodges' comments echo those of security guru Bruce Schneier, who recently warned business to avoid getting "caught up in the feeling of security, driven by fear".

But this doesn't mean that spending on security is a waste of money, according to Hodges, who said that overzealous budgets for securing infrastructure are wasteful because their relationship to a company's financial performance is more tenuous than say, data leakage.

"So what if some IT guys have to work over the weekend to clean up laptops. I mean, I'm sorry to say this but you know that's generally the way a CEO would feel.

"On the other hand, that same CEO, if he thought he was going to be embarrassed and the stock price depressed through a major data leak, he would be very happy to make that investment--and I think that's well beyond the feeling of security," Hodges told ZDNet Asia sister site ZDNet.com.au.

Schneier said that another problem faced by administrators is knowing how much security products are worth.

"If you've ever see one of those ROI models, what they do is measure the cost of an attack and then multiply it by the probability of an attack to give you how much money you should spend--this is how all insurance companies build their business model," Schneier told ZDNet.com.au in an interview.

"Maybe your reputation is worth US$20 million, or maybe it is only worth US$10 million, or maybe it is worth US$40 million. Suddenly I can completely perturb your budget--because the numbers are so big and so small, that minor changes perceptually make huge changes to the product. So I can make an ROI model say whatever I want," he added.


WORTHWHILE?

0

0 votes
Blog

Talkback 0 comments

There are currently no comments for this post.


Tech Jobs Now!

Search for your ideal tech job:

Common ways IT wastes money on development

Web Development

Examples include using developers as support staff and failing to calculate a project's ROI before giving it the go-ahead.


Read more »



  • Enterprise 2.0

    Vince Casarez, vice president of product management at Oracle, explains how Web 2.0 technologies, such as tags, wikis, and mash-ups, can be applied within an organization.
    Play video


  • Nehalem Architecture

    What makes next-generation Intel® Microarchitecture (Nehalem) such a superior successor?
    Play video

 
Free the untapped potential of your IT infrastructure
Reduce bottlenecks to drive the efficiency and productivity of Business IT.
» Ultimate virtualization blade
» Scalable SAN solution
» Accelerate service delivery
On demand CRM goes strategic
CRM technology has come of age, and is now able to align with your customer strategy and grow in step with your business.

» Learn more about Oracle’s CRM Solutions




Could this be the most critical budget for India?

Blog thumbnail

For business journalists in India, budget time is excitement time. It's like sports journos covering the Olympics. As a newspaper correspondent, I too had my fill of budget-time excitement. But..... by Swati Prasad

Read more »

Tags

  1. attack
  2. bank
  3. blog
  4. data security
  5. e - mail
  6. hacking
  7. internet
  8. malware
  9. microsoft corp.
  10. network
  11. network security
  12. pc security
  13. researcher
  14. security
  15. security management
  16. software
  17. spam and phishing
  18. u.s.
  19. viruses and worms
  20. web